StogieRate.com logo

StogieRate.com profile for Pudealee

Pudealee profile picture

Member since

2016

Location

Somewhere in a cloud of smoke

Reviews written

129


Montecristo Classic, Churchill

I hadn't had a Churchill in quite a while. The foot of this stick was a little frayed, but did not hamper the initial burn. Also, a bit of the wrapper...

83.5

Avg
Created: 9/8/2016 by Pudealee

Acid by Drew Estate Acid Gold, Earthiness (Petit Corona)

A new ACID for me. The closed foot didn't make a lot of sense to me. This cigar looked well built, and had the normal, hard to describe, ACID pre-ligh...

82.0

Avg
Created: 9/5/2018 by Pudealee

Montecristo (Cuba) Regular Production, No. 4

Very tight draw from the beginning through to the end. I was surprised at this. It did produce a lot of good smoke regardless. Great tobacco flavor, w...

88.9

Avg
Created: 9/4/2016 by Pudealee

Rocky Patel Decade, Robusto

At first light the draw was so loose that I assumed that the wrapper had a hole in it somewhere. It was producing great smoke, so I guess it was just ...

85.0

Avg
Created: 9/3/2016 by Pudealee

Oliva Cigar Company Serie O, Torpedo

Very nice afternoon smoke. No real outstanding flavors to report. Taste and strength were both on the mild side. It produced a lot of good smoke.

84.3

Avg
Created: 9/28/2016 by Pudealee

Romeo y Julieta (Cuba) Regular Production, Churchills (Red/White Tubo)

For the first time in a long time, a Churchill that I did not get tired of before the end. I was given this sick by a friend, and it sat in my humidor...

90.7

Avg
Created: 9/26/2016 by Pudealee

Jose L. Piedra (Cuba) Regular Production, Brevas

This time around Jose did not disappoint. The overall flavor and experience of this second attempt at a Jose L. Piedra Brevas was better than the firs...

82.6

Avg
Created: 9/26/2016 by Pudealee

Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 50 Years, Robusto

This was my first Torano in quite a long time. This stick had a very good look and feel. Pre-light aroma was wonderful. At first light I picked up a s...

87.1

Avg
Created: 9/23/2016 by Pudealee

Romeo y Julieta (Cuba) Regular Production, Petit Coronas

This was a nice looking stick. The post-light foot smell was wonderful. The start was a nice pepper flavor. The only downside to this, hence the low b...

82.1

Avg
Created: 9/21/2016 by Pudealee

Rocky Patel Java Mint, Corona

I think this was number 8 of this batch. Still not a fan. This one didn't have nearly as bad a "menthol" flavor as the previous ones. Still, Java has ...

73.5

Avg
Created: 9/20/2018 by Pudealee

See all reviews by Pudealee